What is Versus?

SportsWriters has created Versus. A new way to compare and debate articles written by two sports writers with clashing views. SportsWriters identifies a hot topic and locates two writers (typically from different markets) who have expressed an opinion on that topic, and have written an article with supporting arguments.

The result is a thought provoking opinion match up.

  • Versus presents each article, side by side, with a summary of key points.
  • Readers can rate the match up, and comment on who makes the more compelling argument.
  • Directly below the match up, readers provide their critical comments.
  • What makes Versus unique, is that you can see how each commenter voted, and you can rate their comment.
  • Writers get rated on their article, and Members on their comments.

Everything is up for debate with Versus!

February 15, 2021

Versus

Is the Universal DH good/bad for MLB?

Due to the COVID-19 Pandemic, MLB instituted the Designated Hitter rule for both the American League and the National League in 2020.  Joel Sherman of the NY Post states that the Universal DH is great for the game and should continue while Michael Brendan Dougherty of the National Review is firmly against it.

Is the Universal DH good/bad for MLB?

photo: Creative Commons

  • MLB should cave on universal DH for good of the game: Sherman

    Teams near unanimously want the designated hitter in the National League this year. The union is totally in favor. Yet, at this moment, there is no universal DH for 2021.

    Read full article
  • Against the Universal DH

    MLB commissioner Rob Manfred, the owners of baseball’s thirty major-league clubs, and the players union haven’t quite yet agreed to play games this year. The only thing they have agreed to do is to erase a hallowed tradition, by expanding the designated hitter to the National League for this season.

    Read full article

Key points:

MLB should cave on universal DH for good of the game: Sherman

MLB does not want to relent and just apply the universal DH because It would be giving away something for nothing.

MLB hardly wants union leadership crowing to its constituency: “See if we hang tight and keep saying, ‘no,’ MLB will eventually cave.”

MLB should violate Negotiating 101 anyway because it is right for the game.

Is the Universal DH good/bad for MLB?

The triumph of the designated hitter over the National League is a triumph of intellectual sloth and self-delusion.

In reality both the authorities in baseball and the authorities on baseball have blinded themselves to the value of tradition and continuity to the game itself.

It is, in short, time to stand athwart baseball yelling Stop!

80%

20%

Best argument

Neutral

Best argument

3 comments on this Post:

  • RickC

    February 17, 2021 10:28 pm

    Flag

    I like the argument for the universal DH. It would be good for the game.

  • Lance Casual

    February 15, 2021 2:54 pm

    Flag

    Pitchers still have an advantage even with the DH. Let's keep more hitting in the game!

  • NeverMore1

    February 15, 2021 2:53 pm

    Flag

    The DH makes MLB unique, and adds to the intrigue of the game. Why mess with tradition?

Feedback